How Much Wagyu Per Person for Thanksgiving? (And the One Roast That Feeds the Table)
Plan on about 8 ounces of raw wagyu per person if it's the main event. If it's sharing the table with a turkey, 6 ounces is plenty. By that math, one whole 4 to 4.5 pound picanha feeds 8 people as the centerpiece, or 10 to 12 as the second protein.
You don't need a steak for every guest. You need one roast.
How much raw beef should I buy per person?
Beef loses weight when it cooks. Fat renders out and moisture leaves the meat, so the raw weight on the label is always more than what ends up on the plate. That's why we plan in raw ounces.
- Wagyu is the main course. About 8 oz raw per adult.
- Wagyu is next to a turkey or ham. About 6 oz raw per adult.
- Kids and light eaters. Count them as half.
Wagyu is rich, so most people eat a little less of it than they would of a lean steak. If your family fights over leftovers, size up.
| Whole picanha roast | As the main (about 8 oz each) | Next to the turkey (about 6 oz each) |
|---|---|---|
| 3.5 to 4 lb | 7 to 8 people | 9 to 10 people |
| 4 to 4.5 lb | 8 to 9 people | 10 to 12 people |
| 4.5 to 5 lb | 9 to 10 people | 12 to 13 people |
| 5.5 to 6 lb | 11 to 12 people | 14 to 16 people |
Why a whole roast beats a steak per guest
Ten steaks on a holiday means cooking in batches, juggling everyone's doneness and feeding half the table while the other half waits. A roast cooks once, rests once and gets sliced at the table. Everybody eats at the same time.
It also goes further. Sliced thin, one roast puts wagyu on every plate.
Which cut makes the best Thanksgiving roast?
Picanha. It's the sirloin cap, a triangle-shaped cut with a thick fat cap on one side. That cap renders as it cooks and adds richness to every slice. Our picanha guide goes deeper on the cut.
We carry whole picanha roasts in three Australian Wagyu grades.
- Green Label (BMS 4/5). The value pick. Still wagyu, still a crowd-pleaser.
- Silver Label (BMS 6/7). The sweet spot for most tables.
- Gold Label (BMS 8/9). More marbling, richer bite. Our most marbled picanha.
Want the full breakdown? Read BMS Marbling Scores Explained.
How do I cook a whole wagyu picanha?
This is how we cooked ours. Go by a thermometer, not the clock. Roast size changes the time.
- Thaw it in the fridge. Plan on two days or more for a whole roast. Make sure it's fully thawed before it cooks, and don't thaw it on the counter.
- Score the fat cap. Shallow crosshatch, don't cut into the meat. Coat it with a thin layer of mustard and your favorite rub. Got time? Salt it the night before.
- Cook it low and slow. 250 to 275Β°F on the grill over indirect heat, or in the oven at the same temp. Ours took about 2 hours to hit around 150Β°F inside.
- Rest it. Let it sit before you slice.
- Slice thin, against the grain. This is the step that makes or breaks picanha.
Why 150Β°F? We take ours past medium-rare on purpose. The extra time gives that fat cap a chance to render, so it eats soft and juicy instead of chewy. Prefer it pinker? Pull it a little earlier. For the record, USDA recommends 145Β°F with a 3-minute rest for beef roasts, and our 150Β°F clears that.
When should I order for Thanksgiving?
We ship Monday through Wednesday only, so your box never sits in a warehouse over a weekend.
- Standard shipping. Order by Wednesday, November 18 at 1pm PT.
- After that. Choose Overnight and order by Sunday, November 22. Our final shipment before the holiday goes out Monday, November 23.
Carriers get slammed this time of year, so earlier is better. Whole roasts are limited and the popular sizes go first. Details are on our shipping page.
FAQ
Is a 4 pound wagyu roast enough for 10 people?
Yes, if there's a turkey too. At 6 oz raw each, a 4 to 4.5 lb roast covers 10 to 12. If it's the only main, plan on 8 or 9.
Should I trim the fat cap?
No. That's the good part. If someone wants a leaner slice, trim theirs after it's cooked.
Can I make it in the oven instead of the grill?
Yes. Same low temp, same thermometer. Cook time and flavor can come out a little different, so go by temp.
Is your Australian wagyu picanha Halal?
Yes. Our Green, Silver and Gold Label picanha is Halal certified.
Shop whole picanha roasts
One roast. The whole table.